Shipping & Returns

Shipping Policy:

We offer FREE shipping on all orders over $150 before tax.  Any order less than $150 before tax charges a $7 flat rate shipping fee. [Exclusions may apply for separate promotions.]

Generally, we ship out the same day, or the following business day, depending on what time you place your order.  Almost all items are shipped directly from our storefront in Decorah.  A few items are shipped directly from an offsite warehouse.  Those products are identified with ✜ ONLINE EXCLUSIVE ✜ noted at the end of the product title.  

We offer free local pickup at our store located at 101 East Water Street, Decorah, IA, 52101.  You will receive an automated e-mail when your order is ready for pickup.  You may use the free local pickup for ✜ONLINE EXCLUSIVE✜ items, but please be aware it will take a couple of days for those items to arrive at our store from the warehouse.

Please note that your order may not come in the original box.  We take pride in recycling and doing our part to care for the environment.  We will utilize the smallest box possible to allow for priority shipping.  Please follow our lead and RECYCLE! :)

If your order tracking shows "delivered," but you haven't received it, please contact your local post office.  Your local post office or UPS store will GPS the package to locate it for you.  If it shows "delivered" and they cannot find your package, please contact your local law enforcement or file a claim with USPS/UPS.  Broker Leather is not responsible for packages after they leave our store.


Return Policy:

Our Return Policy [as printed on the bottom of your original receipt or on the reverse side of your packing slip] is as follows:

Refunds for store credit on full-price items in their original condition [tags attached, no signs of wear and tear, free from pet hair/pet smell/cigarette smoke/stains, etc.] will be offered up to 30 days from the purchase date. Returns/exchanges cannot be accepted after 30 days.

To complete your return, the form on the reverse side of your packing slip must be included with the product you are returning. Any returns submitted without this accompanying form [or an original receipt for an in-store purchase] will not be eligible for store credit.

The customer is responsible for paying shipping costs for returning the goods. ALL Shipping costs are non-refundable. The original cost of shipping incurred by Broker Leather will be deducted from your store credit. If you applied a discount code to complete your purchase the amount deducted will not be included in the store credit refund and further access to that code may be revoked by the computer system.

Your store credit refund request will be processed within 2-4 business days of receiving your returned package. You will be issued sufficient funds in-store credit via the e-mail address attached to the qualifying order. Store credit does not expire and can be used in-store and/or online.

Gift cards, Sale Barn items, any item sold at a discount, hats, wild rags, sunglasses, and all jewelry are FINAL SALE.

To complete your return, we require a receipt or packing slip as proof of purchase.  Please include your receipt or packing slip in the box/bag you are returning.

To return your goods, please mail to:

Broker Leather

101 E. Water St

Decorah, IA 52101 

The customer is responsible for paying shipping costs for returning your goods. Shipping costs are non-refundable. If you qualify to receive a refund, the original cost of return shipping incurred by Broker Leather will be deducted from your refund.

If you are shipping an item over $75, you should consider using a trackable shipping service or purchasing shipping insurance. We cannot guarantee that we will receive your returned item.

Sale Barn Goods [if applicable]
Only regular-priced items may be refunded, any goods sold at a discount cannot be returned.  All of these items state this portion of the policy very clearly in the product description.


Please follow the return policy above to exchange your goods for a different size.  Once you receive your store credit gift card via e-mail, you can place a separate order online for your desired size (or an entirely different item, if you prefer!)